The market determines what a home is worth. The seller determines whether it sells.
After 19 years of selling real estate in Toronto and the GTA, I've learned that there are many things that contribute to a successful sale. Preparation, pricing, photography, marketing, exposure, negotiation and the experience of the realtor all matter.
But when all those things have been done properly, and the home is still not selling, I often find myself coming back to one factor: seller motivation.
That doesn't mean a seller should accept any offer.
Far from it.
It means understanding what the market is telling us, separating expectations from evidence and deciding what to do with that information.
So what exactly is the market telling us?
1. Before We List: What a Comparative Market Analysis Really Tells Us
One of the most important parts of my work happens before a property ever reaches MLS.
When I prepare a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA), I look at far more than the prices of recently sold homes.
I want to understand the entire market surrounding that property.
Expired listings: What didn't sell, and why?
An expired listing tells me that a property was offered to the market but didn't sell during its listing period. That doesn't automatically mean the price was wrong. There may have been issues with presentation, condition, access, location or marketing.
It tells me that the combination of price, property and marketing wasn't enough to produce a sale.
I want to dig deeper and understand why.
Active listings: What are we competing against?
Buyers don't evaluate your home in isolation.
If someone is looking for a semi-detached home in Markham with a budget of approximately $1 million, they are comparing every reasonable option available to them.
What does your property offer that the others don't? Is it better maintained? Does it have a larger lot? A better layout? More updates?
And, importantly, is the asking price competitive?
Stale listings: Where is the market hesitating?
I pay close attention to similar homes that have been sitting for three or four weeks without selling.
If a comparable property has been available for 30 days at $1.1 million without attracting an acceptable offer, I wouldn't ignore that information when pricing another similar property.
I would investigate what might be preventing the sale.
Recently sold properties: What have buyers actually paid?
This is some of our strongest evidence.
An asking price tells us what a seller hopes to receive. A completed sale tells us what a buyer was willing to pay and a seller was willing to accept.
But I don't stop at the sold price.
I review the listing history.
How long was the home on the market? Was it originally listed higher? Were there price reductions? Was it re-listed? Did it sell quickly after an adjustment?
Two properties may have sold for the same amount but followed very different paths to get there.
That history matters.
A good CMA doesn't simply tell us what sold. It helps us understand what buyers are accepting, rejecting and comparing.
2. What Actually Attracts Buyers?
Once we understand the market, our job is to make the property as attractive as possible.
This means professional photography, good lighting, cleanliness, thoughtful staging or excellent preparation, a strong listing description and proper exposure.
First impressions matter.
A dark, cluttered room can make a perfectly good home feel smaller. Poor photography can prevent a buyer from booking a showing in the first place.
And a home that looks neglected may raise concerns about maintenance.
These are things we can control.
But even a beautifully presented home has to compete on price.
A buyer might love your kitchen, your backyard and your floor plan. But if a similar home offers comparable features for substantially less, that buyer has an easy decision to make.
Marketing creates the opportunity to be seen. Presentation creates interest. Price must make sense to the buyer.
3. The First 7, 14 and 21 Days: How I Read Market Feedback
Once a home is listed, the work doesn't stop. This is when we begin receiving direct feedback from the market.
I pay particular attention to the first three weeks.
Day 7: Are We Attracting Buyers?
During the first week, I'm looking at showing activity, inquiries, feedback and competing listings.
If we are receiving a healthy number of showings, that's encouraging. It means the property has attracted enough interest for buyers to come and see it.
But if there are very few showings, I want to understand why.
Is the home being exposed to the right audience?
Are the photographs doing it justice?
Is the property easy to show, or are restricted showing times making it difficult for buyer agents to book appointments? Have new competing properties come onto the market?
If the home is well prepared, properly marketed and easy to show, but buyers still aren't booking appointments, price becomes a leading concern.
Day 14: Why Haven't We Received an Offer?
In my experience, approximately 7–10 qualified showings can be enough to generate an offer when a property is well positioned.
That's not a published TRREB benchmark or a guarantee. It is a practical expectation I've developed through my own transactions.
If we've had 7–10 showings without an offer, I want answers.
I call the agents who have shown the property.
Not all agents are willing or able to provide detailed feedback, but I make the effort because those conversations are valuable.
I ask what their buyers thought.
What other properties are they considering?
What did they like?
What concerns did they raise?
And I ask a question that often tells me more than a standard feedback form:
"If the price was right, would your buyers consider this home?"
Sometimes the answer is no.
Maybe the railway is too close, the school is too far away or the layout simply doesn't meet the buyers’ needs.
Those are things we can't change.
For that particular buyer, a reasonable price reduction may make no difference.
But sometimes the answer is “maybe”.
Now we have something to explore.
What price would make the home worth reconsidering? What other property are they comparing it with? Is there a specific concern we can address?
And if the answer is yes, I want to understand what's stopping them from making an offer.
This is an important part of my job.
I don't just collect feedback. I try to understand what it means and what we can do about it.
One buyer's objection isn't necessarily a market trend. But when several buyers raise the same concern, I pay attention.
Day 21: Is Our Strategy Working?
By the third week, we should have a clearer picture of how buyers are responding.
If we've had good exposure and multiple showings but no offers, we need to review the feedback and our position against the competition.
If comparable properties have sold while ours remains available, that is important information.
If we've had almost no showings, despite excellent presentation and marketing, I would be having a serious conversation about price.
Not because every property must sell within 21 days.
But because continuing with a strategy that isn't producing results deserves careful examination.
4. How Long Does It Take to Sell a House in Markham?
According to the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board's October 2026 Market Watch, the average listing days on market in Markham were approximately:
- 30 days across all home types.
- 29 days for detached homes.
- 30 days for semi-detached homes.
In that month, 260 properties sold in Markham, with an average selling price of $1,117,006.
These are useful benchmarks, but they don't tell us how long your particular home should take to sell.
A well-priced home in a desirable location may attract an offer quickly. Another property may require more time because of its condition, price range, features or competition.
And remember, average listing days on market reflect sold listings. They don't mean every home on the market will sell within that period.
That's why I focus on what is happening with the individual property rather than relying on one market average.
5. Still Thinking About 2022 Prices? Also look at the Home You Are Buying Next.
This is a conversation I believe more move-up buyers and sellers should be having.
Many homeowners remember what their property might have sold for at the height of the market in early 2022.
And understandably, selling for less today can feel like a loss.
But what about the home you are planning to buy?
If you are moving from a semi-detached home to a detached home in Markham, the price of that larger property has changed too.
Let's look at the actual market data.
Markham Home Prices: February 2022 vs. October 2026
Property type | February 2022 | October 2026 | Change |
Semi-detached | $1,533,993 | $977,350 | −36.3% |
Detached | $2,126,548 | $1,522,789 | −28.4% |
Source: TRREB Market Watch, February 2022 and October 2026. Figures represent average selling prices, not the change in value of individual properties.
The average semi-detached selling price declined by approximately $557,000, while the average detached selling price declined by approximately $604,000.
So what happened to the price difference between the two?
In February 2022, the gap between the average semi-detached and detached selling prices was approximately $593,000.
By October 2026, that gap was approximately $545,000.
That's a narrowing of roughly $47,000.
Interestingly, semi-detached homes experienced the larger percentage decline, even though detached homes experienced the larger dollar decline.
This is why we should not assume that every larger home has fallen more in value, or that every move-up buyer is automatically better off.
The specific properties matter.
So do financing costs, land transfer taxes, commissions and other expenses.
There's also an important limitation to monthly average prices: the homes sold in February 2022 are not the same homes sold in October 2026. The mix of properties can affect the averages.
But the broader lesson remains.
If you are selling one home to buy another, you need to evaluate both sides of the transaction.
What you could have sold for in 2022 is no longer the only relevant number.
What your next home will cost you today may be just as important.
6. So Why Do Some Homes Still Not Sell? Let's Talk About Motivation.
After all the research, preparation, marketing, showings and feedback, we eventually reach a decision.
The market has given us information.
Maybe buyers are consistently choosing competing properties.
Maybe we've received offers below the seller's expectations. Or perhaps there has been very little interest at the current asking price.
At that point, I believe motivation becomes critical.
There is a difference between wanting to sell and being willing to sell at a price supported by today's market.
Some sellers are still anchored to what their property might have been worth in 2022. Others have a number in mind based on what they believe the home deserves.
I understand both.
A home is often someone's largest asset. It is also where they have raised a family, celebrated milestones and built memories.
But the market doesn't price those memories.
And it doesn't know what a seller hopes to receive.
Buyers compare available properties and decide what they are prepared to pay.
Of course, there are homeowners who cannot sell below a certain amount because of financial constraints. That is something I believe should be discussed before listing. If the numbers don't work, selling may not be the right decision.
But when selling is financially possible, the home has been properly prepared and marketed and the market has given us consistent feedback, the seller must decide how to respond.
Adjust the price?
Wait for market conditions to change?
Withdraw the property?
These are all legitimate choices.
A seller is never obligated to accept an offer simply because it's the best one currently available.
But we should also recognize that choosing to hold out for a higher price may mean choosing not to sell in the current market or for a good while.
And there is nothing wrong with that, provided it is an informed decision.
7. What Should You Do If Your Markham Home Isn't Selling?
Before making another price reduction or changing agents, I would want to review the entire listing.
Was the original price supported by a thorough CMA?
How does the home compare with what's available today?
Have competing properties sold? How many qualified showings have taken place?
What did buyers say?
Were there offers?
What changed during the listing period?
And, perhaps most importantly, what is the seller trying to accomplish?
Sellers' reason for selling doesn't change the property's market value.
But their goals, timing and motivation determine which decisions make sense for them.
The market determines what a home is worth. The seller determines whether it sells.
My responsibility is to provide the research, preparation, marketing, feedback and negotiation expertise to help my clients make those decisions with confidence.
And sometimes the best advice is not to reduce the price.
Sometimes it is to wait.
The important thing is to understand why.
Thinking About Selling Your Home in Markham?
Whether you are considering moving up, downsizing or selling a property that hasn't attracted the interest you expected, I can help you understand what the current market is telling us.
A proper market analysis looks beyond asking prices and sold properties. It considers the competition, listing histories, buyer behaviour and your next move.
Let's look at the numbers, the strategy and your options before making a decision.
Raluca Neagu
Real Estate Broker | RE/MAX Realtron Realty Inc., Brokerage
19 years of real estate experience serving Markham, Toronto and the GTA.
.png)